Skip to main content

Dexter Ice Cream & Cafe

Colorful blue and yellow front of Dexter ice Cream & Cafe.

Nestled in the heart of quaint Downtown Dexter, Dexter Ice Cream & Cafe stands vibrantly as a testament to the town’s rich history and culinary delights. Owners Donna and Brian have masterfully transformed this historic building into a cool hotspot that draws both residents and visitors alike.

Scoops Of Delight

At Dexter Ice Cream & Cafe, the menu is a delightful fusion of classic treats and comfort creations. The star of the show is undoubtedly the Bluebell Ice Cream, a favorite among patrons for its rich, creamy texture and wide array of flavors. Can’t pick just one? Try their four and six flavor flights, to share or to splurge.

The offerings extend beyond just ice cream. Owners Donna and Brian have brought a taste of New York City to Dexter, Georgia with their selection of bagels sourced directly from the Big Apple, along with sandwiches, danishes, and hot dogs! Among the many tempting options, one standout sammy has garnered a following: the homemade Mac and Cheese grilled cheese. This masterpiece combines the comfort of creamy, homemade mac and cheese with the satisfying crunch of a perfectly toasted sandwich, creating a flavor experience that… you have to try.

Coffee, anyone? Pair your pastries with a hot or cold espresso or cappuccino. Customize your beverage to your hearts content with their self-serve flavor bar.

Handful Of History

The cafe itself is a feast for the eyes, with its brightly colored exterior inviting passersby to step inside and experience its warm, welcoming atmosphere. The historic charm of the building is reflected on the walls inside, with a lineup of historic black and white photos of Dexter, GA providing a nostalgic backdrop for the modern, delectable offerings served within. Fun fact: The building Dexter ice Cream & Cafe now occupies was once the home of the original Lord’s Sausage location.

Dexter Ice Cream & Cafe is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community hub where friends gather, families celebrate, and memories are made. Whether stopping in for a quick treat or sitting in for a leisurely meal, guests can always expect top-notch service and a menu that promises to delight.